The Doctrine of Sola Scriptura is not taught anywhere in the Bible. Perhaps the most striking reason for rejecting this doctrine is that there is not one verse defense of Sola Scriptura, but close examination of these two passages easily Biblical canon a the Council of Trent in – naming the very same list of 73 books.
Table of contents
- Books by Roger LeBlanc (Author of The Bible Alone vs. the Virgin Mary)
- Frequently bought together
- Books by Roger LeBlanc
- Customers who bought this item also bought
If you know someone who is on the brink of conversion, give them this book and you will join them at the next Easter Vigil. When I give talks on Theology, this is one book I tell people they should read. One of my favorite lines from the book is - "Twelve simple, uneducated fisherman, revolutionized the world, and that with no other instrument than their new faith and their readiness to die for that faith.
Books by Roger LeBlanc (Author of The Bible Alone vs. the Virgin Mary)
This book is considered to be the best available by respected converts such as Thomas Howard and Scott Hahn. Adam covers all the most important points in a short book, and he covers them very well. This is a brilliant description of what Catholicism is all about -- a must-read for Catholics and non-Catholics alike, particularly for those who believe that the Church is nothing more than a tyrannical, despotic body that kills reason and self-discovery in the name of absolute obedience. One of the strengths of this book is that Adam frequently quotes the leading Protestant thinkers of his day in order to show the limitations of Protestantism generally.
To his credit, Adam is never judgmental or hostile to non-Catholics. On the contrary, he goes to great lengths to show just how open-minded the Church is regarding non-Catholic and non-Christian beliefs, and what is positive and helpful about them. I was very surprised to find how little I knew about the complexities of, for example, the Church's position on salvation through the Church, and the role of individual conscience and freedom in faith.
Adam shows, very convincingly, that the Catholic Church is exceedingly fair, open, reasonable, and caring in its approach to these controversial and widely misunderstood issues. His approach is always positive, hopeful, and logical. His arguments are iron-clad, rooted in Scripture, and absolutely devastating. Adam's book is extremely valuable and must be read if one wishes to gain a real understanding of Catholicism in a short book.
Whether you are a Catholic seeking to know more about your ancient faith or a non-Catholic seeking to learn about Catholic beliefs, Adam's book is required reading. You'll be surprised at what you find within these pages, and perhaps even ashamed that you believed all the half-truths and distortions about Catholicism. Let the reader beware: See all 13 reviews.
Most recent customer reviews. Published 1 year ago.
- Twenty One Reasons to Reject Sola Scriptura;
- Sola scriptura - Wikipedia!
- .
- Desires of My Heart - Meditation on Psalm 37:4.
- Newsletter.
Published on December 1, Published on April 4, Published on April 7, Published on January 23, Published on July 7, Amazon Giveaway allows you to run promotional giveaways in order to create buzz, reward your audience, and attract new followers and customers. Learn more about Amazon Giveaway.
The Spirit of Catholicism. Set up a giveaway. Customers who viewed this item also viewed. There's a problem loading this menu right now. Get fast, free shipping with Amazon Prime. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations. View or edit your browsing history. Get to Know Us. English Choose a language for shopping. Amazon Music Stream millions of songs. Amazon Drive Cloud storage from Amazon.
Frequently bought together
Alexa Actionable Analytics for the Web. AmazonGlobal Ship Orders Internationally. Amazon Inspire Digital Educational Resources. Amazon Rapids Fun stories for kids on the go. Amazon Restaurants Food delivery from local restaurants. ComiXology Thousands of Digital Comics. East Dane Designer Men's Fashion. Learn more about Amazon Prime. Read more Read less. Prime Book Box for Kids. Add both to Cart Add both to List. One of these items ships sooner than the other.
Buy the selected items together This item: Customers who bought this item also bought. Page 1 of 1 Start over Page 1 of 1. Uncovering the Biblical Foundations of Catholicism. The Case for Catholicism: Answers to Classic and Contemporary Protestant Objections. Surprised by Truth 3: Why Is That in Tradition? Sponsored products related to this item What's this? The King James Only Debate: A Reformed Baptist Primer.
Atheism, Darwinism, feminism, Marxism, all attacks on the Bible but all finding safe haven in the modern church. From the Shadows to the Savior: Christ in the Old Testament. We all know Christ is somehow in the Old Testament. Sons of the Gods. Giants, demons, and other supernatural things in the Bible?
Sponsored Products are advertisements for products sold by merchants on Amazon. Review Dave lays out what sola Scriptura is by quoting from several Protestant apologists and scholars no straw-men here and then dives right in to the arguments against the doctrine. Catholic Answers May 10, Language: Related Video Shorts 0 Upload your video. Try the Kindle edition and experience these great reading features: Share your thoughts with other customers.
Write a customer review. Read reviews that mention authority tradition church catholic bible apologist scripture protestants armstrong god protestant beginning doctrine pages christian protestantism teaching quoting dave faith. There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later. Kindle Edition Verified Purchase. Excellent resource on explaining the fallacy of Sola Scriptura or Scripture alone. Helps the apologist explain why Sola Scriptura is not scriptural.
Convincing in his arguments. This book helps settle the matter of authority for Christians. Who do you listen too? Reformers who taught sola Scriptura or the tradition that has been passed down from the beginning. Paul both commends and commands the keeping of oral tradition. In 1 Corinthians Protestantism, by comparison, has known a history of doctrinal vacillations and changes, and no two denominations completely agree — even on major doctrinal issues.
Since in practice the beliefs of Protestantism have undergone change both within denominations and through the continued appearance of new denominations, these beliefs are like a foundation which shifts and moves. Such beliefs therefore cease to provide the support necessary to maintain the structure they uphold, and the integrity of that structure becomes compromised, Our Lord clearly did not intend for His followers to build their spiritual houses on such an unreliable foundation.
It is extremely telling in this instance that Our Lord identifies the Church rather than Scripture as the final authority to be appealed to. The Catholic Church readily acknowledges the inerrancy and authority of Scripture. Philip and the Ethiopian eunuch. In this scenario, the Holy Spirit leads Philip to approach the Ethiopian when Philip learns that the Ethiopian is reading from the prophet Isaias, he asks him a very telling question:.
There is also 2 Peter 1: The question that begs to be asked, therefore, is this: Persecutions had already begun, believers were being martyred, the new Faith was struggling to grow, and some false teachings had already appeared cf. It was the Church, in effect, which wrote the Bible under the inspiration of Almighty God: If you look at the writings of the Early Church Fathers, you will see references to the Apostolic Succession, 10 to the bishops as guardians of the Deposit of Faith, 11 and to the primacy and the authority of Rome.
How much more absurd, then, is it to contend that the Bible could function on its own and apart from the Church which wrote it? In fact, an examination of the state of affairs in Europe immediately following the genesis of the Reformation — particularly in Germany — will demonstrate that the direct result of Reformation teaching was both spiritual and social disorder.
If you look at the history of the early Church, you will see that it continually struggled against heresies and those who promoted them. We also see the Church responding to those threats again and again by convening Councils 15 and turning to Rome to settle disputes in matters of doctrine and discipline.
A good illustration of this point is the case of Arius, the 4 th -century priest who declared that the Son of God was a creature and was not co-equal with the Father. The issue, then, becomes a question of how we can know what that true interpretation is. The only possible answer is that there must be, out of necessity, an infallible authority to tell us. That infallible authority, the Catholic Church, declared Arius heretical. One historical fact which proves extremely convenient for the Protestant is the fact that the canon of the Bible — the authoritative list of exactly which books are part of inspired Scripture — was not settled and fixed until the end of the 4 th century.
How can one know with certainty which books belong in the Bible — specifically, in the New Testament? Why was there any disagreement at all? Why was the canon of the Bible not identified much earlier if the books were allegedly so readily discernible? The answer that one is compelled to accept in this regard is simply that the Bible is not self-authenticating at all. Even more interesting is the fact that some books in the Bible do not identify their authors. But in this regard the Bible leaves us ignorant in a few instances.
The Protestant may want to assert that not having original Biblical manuscripts is immaterial, as God preserved the Bible by safeguarding its duplication down through the centuries. It has just been noted that there are thousands of Biblical manuscripts in existence; these manuscripts contain thousands of variations in the text; one writer estimates that there are over , variations. More importantly, there are several more major textual variations among New Testament manuscripts. The following two examples will illustrate the point:.
Now this point may seem trivial at first, but suppose you are trying to evangelize a cult member who denies the divinity of Jesus Christ. As mentioned in Point 14 above , there are thousands and thousands of variations in the Biblical manuscripts. This problem is compounded by the fact that history has known hundreds of Bible versions, which vary in translation as well as textual sources. This idea presupposes that each believer possesses a Bible or at least has access to a Bible. On the other hand, we know that God is not cruel at all, but in fact has infinite love for us.
It is for this reason that He did not leave us in darkness. Protestantism in practice bears out this fact. Consequently, if there are many possible interpretations of Scripture, by definition there is no ultimate interpretation. Of course any given denomination within Protestantism would probably maintain that its particular interpretations are the correct ones — at least in practice, if not formally.
If it did not, its adherents would be changing denominations! However, if any given denomination claims that its interpretations are correct above those of the other denominations, it has effectively set itself up as a final authority. Much to their chagrin, Protestants are actually guilty of violating their own doctrine. In defense of their deficient Old Testament canon, Protestants invariably present one or more of the following arguments:. The Septuagint contained the dueterocanonical books. It is therefore unreasonable and presumptuous to say that Christ and His Apostles accepted the shorter Old Testament canon, as the clear majority of the time they used an Old Testament version which did contain the seven books in question.
Or, take the case of Saint Paul, whose missionary journeys and letters were directed to Hellenistic regions outside of Palestine. According to one list, the deutero-canonical books are cited or alluded to in the New Testament not less than times!
Obviously, then, citation by Christ or the Apostles does not singlehandedly determine canonicity. There were many views both inside and outside of Israel in the first centuries B. These Jews most likely accepted the shorter Pharisaic canon precisely because the early Christians accepted the longer Septuagint canon.
- The Complete Bible Answer Book: Collectors Edition;
- .
- Dreams For Kids: Changing the World One Person at a Time.
- Christlife: Embracing Your True and Deepest Identity!
- Research Advances in Rabies: 79 (Advances in Virus Research).
Luther was ultimately persuaded by his friends to retain these books. In addition to the above is the fact of historical testimony and continuity regarding the canon of the Bible. While we have seen that there were disputes regarding the Biblical canon, two considerations are nonetheless true:. If anything at all can be said with certainty about Martin Luther, it is that he was deeply and chronically troubled by a combination of doubts and despair about his salvation and a sense of utter impotence in the face of temptation and sin.
Considering that Luther himself admits to an obsessive concern with his own sinfulness, as well as an inability to resist temptation, it seems reasonable to conclude that he suffered from scrupulosity, and even Lutheran scholars will admit to this. But since the avoidance of sin as well as the performance of good works are necessary components for our salvation, and since these facts were steadfastly taught and defended by the Catholic Church, Luther found himself diametrically opposed to the teaching authority of the Church. In Pope Saint Pius X initiated a revision of the Vulgate to achieve even greater textual accuracy.
After his death, this huge project was carried on by others. Reblogged this on anastpaul and commented: Brilliant — thank you Fr Rolly. Like Liked by 1 person. You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Twitter account. You are commenting using your Facebook account. Notify me of new comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed. What is Sola Scriptura?
Books by Roger LeBlanc
Heresiarchs and heretical movements based their doctrines on Scripture interpreted apart from Tradition and the Magisterium. The Canon of the Bible was not settled until the 4 th Century. By this doctrine, which is one of the foundational beliefs of Protestantism, a Protestant denies that there is any other source of religious authority or divine Revelation to humanity. As far as these abuses were concerned, they were real and Luther was justified in reacting.
He eventually rejected Tradition as well as the teaching authority of the Catholic Church with the Pope at its head as having legitimate religious authority. Luther was clearly passionate about his beliefs, and he was successful in spreading them, but these facts in and of themselves do not guarantee that what he taught was correct. The Doctrine of Sola Scriptura is not taught anywhere in the Bible Perhaps the most striking reason for rejecting this doctrine is that there is not one verse anywhere in the Bible in which it is taught, and it therefore becomes a self-refuting doctrine.
In 2 Timothy 3: Protestants may respond to this issue by arguing that St. The question that begs to be asked, however, is this: Such a question poses a problem for the Protestant, but not for the Catholic, as the latter has an infallible authority to answer it. The fact that this individual is a minister of Christ presupposes that he has already had training and teaching which prepared him to assume his office.
By way of analogy , consider a medical doctor. It is neither the last item on his list or just one prominent item. The doctor also needs his stethoscope, his blood pressure gauge, his training, etc. These other items are presupposed by the fact that we are talking about a doctor rather than a non-medical person. Consider again a medical analogy.
Picture a medical student at the beginning of internship. He might have at his disposal all the equipment necessary to perform an operation i. The Scriptures, like the surgical instruments, are life-giving only when properly used.
Customers who bought this item also bought
When improperly used, the exact opposite results can occur. In once case they could bring physical ruin or even death; in the other case they could bring spiritual ruin or even spiritual death. The passage — almost the very last in the Bible — reads: